Alternative Test Methods: Validation and Regulatory Status

Conventional test method Alternative Test Method Infor- mation Last Updated
Name & Description Validation Status Regulatory Status Effect or Potential Effect on Animal Use
Vaccine Potency - Human Use

Lethal/paralytic challenge test in the batch potency testing of tetanus toxoid vaccines for human use
(Methods A and B in PhEur 2.7.8)

ELISA procedure for Batch Potency Testing of Tetanus Vaccines
Description and references

EU: Endorsed as valid by ECVAM (2000)

EU: Accepted into PhEur (Method C, 2.7.8) (2003)

Reduction
(single-dilution test instead of multi-dilution)

Refinement
(Does not rely on death as an endpoint)

April 2009
Toxin Binding Inhibition (ToBI) Test for Batch Potency Testing  of Tetanus Vaccines
Description and references
EU: Endorsed as valid by ECVAM (2000)

EU: Accepted into PhEur (Method C, 2.7.8) (2003)

Reduction
(single-dilution test instead of multi-dilution)

Refinement
(Does not rely on death as an endpoint)

April 2009

Lethal/Intradermal Challenge Test in the Batch Potency Testing of Diptheria Vaccine
(Methods A and B in PhEur 2.7.6)

ELISA Procedure for Potency testing of Diphtheria Vaccines
Description and references

No information

EU: Accepted into  PhEur

Reduction

Refinement
April 2009
Vero Cell Assay for Potency testing of Diphtheria Vaccines
Description and references

EU: Norwegian Medicines Agency presently conducting validation

EU: Accepted into  PhEur

Reduction

Refinement
April 2009

Combination Tetanus and Diphtheria vaccines – separate serology tests  for each vaccine

Tetanus and Diphtheria Serology test – single test for combination vaccine
Description and references

No information

EU: Accepted into  PhEur

Reduction

April 2009

Potency Test of Hepatitis B Vaccine (Mouse)

Serological Antigen Quantification
Description and references

No Information

EU: Accepted into PhEur ( 2.7.15)

Reduction

Refinement
April 2009

Serological Potency Test of Poliomyelitis (inactivated) Vaccine (Rat)

Antigen quantification
Description and references

No Information

EU: Accepted into PhEur

Replacement

April 2009

Lethal challenge test for Rabies Vaccine

Single dilution assay
Description and references

No Information

EU: Accepted into PhEur

Reduction

April 2009
Humane Endpoints for Rabies Potency Testing
Description and references
US: ICCVAM initiative EU: Accepted in PhEur
US: Accepted (9 CFR 117.e)

Refinement

April 2009

List of Abbreviations